cbsi150.gif (783 bytes)Claremont Behavioral Studies Institute

Edwin Romero

Will's history of abuse and abandonment has led him to believe that he is mean, unlovable, and on his own in the world. He sees change and love as unnecessary risks. He is afraid of being vulnerable because it is incongruent with his self-image, an image he developed in order to function in a lonely, painful world. He has learned to react with anger towards words of affection because, to him, they imply that he is weak and that threatens his identity. He cannot assimilate these unselfish motives with the motives in his existing schemata because he has never known agape. A similar conflict exists with his intelligence. He doesn't see himself as special or worthy of praise. He is comfortable being a poor "Southy" because the mainstream looks down on this group as he's been looked down on all his life.
Will makes choices that will verify his self-concept. He feels comfortable being a poor Southy and wants to stay there all his life. He chooses friends because loyalty and reciprocity are the only aspects of love he can understand from his logical perspective. There are no risks when you don't aspire to dream. On an unconscious level, however, his social "me" is looking for praise, working in a comfortable position amongst bright people where he risks being discovered, and chooses to quit when he does. He chooses to fight and get in trouble in order to confirm to himself that he is mean and belongs with his friends, he needs to belong. In that we can obviously see cultural aspects to Will's feelings and behavior. These activities are their way of forming intimacy. An important choice Will made was to talk to Sean, as Sean applied a Rogerian approach to verify Will's will. Will shares a joke that reveals his antagonism towards the roles that confine him, for example the poor, tough Southy. But, more importantly, he reveals his fear of risks, and decides to continue seeing Skylar.
Then Will makes the biggest mistake of the movie. He lies to Skylar, a mistake I am all too familiar with. When beginning a relationship we play roles that attempt to hide what we believe to be our flaws. These flaws are actually the cornerstones of our identities, deeply symbolizing how we see ourselves. Will doesn't want to seem vulnerable to Skylar. When he reveals the truth, the timing of the disclosure leaves him very vulnerable and he can't control the way he has learned to deal with these emotions. He cannot assimilate Skylar's propositions as being genuine with his beliefs that people want something from him. He chooses to push her away, feeling threatened. He then goes on and rationalizes that he doesn't need the jobs he is offered because he'll be bored. He is afraid of being used, he's afraid to take the risk and change his entire life. He wouldn't be comfortable with it.
To find the antagonist of the story you need look no further than the title of the film. Will Hunter, hunting for the will to reach his potential, against his self-image. The challenge is to conquer his self-defeating behavior in order to unleash his genius. His friends have kept him alive all these years by giving him a sense of belonging, comfort, intimacy, and acceptance. Then, he is given an opportunity to grow, and growth is frightening and difficult. Sean challenges Will to take risks and dares him to love. This relationship helps Will to see the incongruency in his self-image that is not allowing him to grow. Skylar gives Will the experiences that prove to him that he is not as unlovable as he thinks.
The timing and quality of these relationships proved to be exactly what Will needed to get "unstuck". His friends show him that he was special with a gift. His best friend reveals that he did not expect or want him to give up this opportunity, and that he would not lose his friendship. This helped Will see the opportunity and the real reason why he didn't want to take it. Sean gave Will goals to reach and taught him the flaw in his thinking, "It is not your fault". The past was not his fault, he is not a bad person, and he cannot avoid risks all his life by thinking of what can go wrong. Will finally heard what Sean was saying and realized his resistance. Will's sense of self has changed at the resolution of the movie. He takes a risk and goes after Skylar. Surely he is vulnerable, but the qualia of love cannot be felt in any book, and there exists no other risk so worthy of the taking.

Return to:   Film And The Issue Of Identity              Therapeutic Cinema
Copyright 2000 Claremont Behavioral Studies Institute

Use of this site constitutes your acceptance
of these Terms of Use
For information regarding this site
please contact the

Last modified: 18 March, 2009