If
you could have found out what
that Rosebud meant, I bet that
wouldve explained
everything.
No,
I dont. Not much anyway.
Charles Foster Kane was a man who
got everything he wanted, and
then lost it. Maybe Rosebud was
something he couldnt get or
something he lost, but it
wouldnt have explained
anything. I dont think any
word explains a mans life.
No --- I guess Rosebud is just a
piece in a jigsaw puzzle -- a
missing piece.
Rosebud is a dying
mans last word, and for
approximately one hundred and fifteen
minutes we witness the search for its
meaning and the meaning of Charles
Foster Kanes life. From the
accounts of a number of people we
learn a lot about Charlie Kane, but
as we near the end of the movie we,
like the reporter Thompson, feel that
Rosebud will remain a mystery, a
piece of a puzzle that probably
doesnt explain much of
anything, anyhow. In the final scene,
the camera sweeps over a vast floor
piled with crated artworks and
objects acquired by Kane. The
collection is greater than a
pharaohs treasure. Mixed in
with the priceless is worthless stuff
which is being thrown into a blazing
furnace. As the camera moves closer
to the open furnace, an object is
tossed in. We see what it is.
As the camera moves even closer we
discover that the object is Rosebud,
and the meaning of Kanes dying
word becomes clear.
Most of you who are reading this have
seen Citizen Kane, and know
what Rosebud is. (If you havent
seen the movie Im not going to
spoil the experience by revealing the
mystery). Seeing Rosebud being
consumed by fire, we understand what
happened to Charlie Kane, even if we
cannot put that understanding into
words.
Its probably accurate to say
that each persons first viewing
is an unique experience and almost
always remembered. This is a film
that causes a variety of
reactions. A number of years
ago, before there were video players,
I had a 16mm projector and showed Citizen
Kane to my wife and kids and
another couple who had come over with
their children. Everyone enjoyed the
experience except my friends
nine year old son. The film terrified
him and that night he had nightmares,
dreaming that he had been taken away
from his parents. Needless to say he
understood the meaning of Rosebud on
a level much deeper than most of us.
In psychological terms, Citizen
Kane is about abandonment and a
mans life of futile striving to
recover from that abandonment. What I
and most psychologists know is that a
person cannot resolve such a deep,
painful issue by looking outward to
other people and things to heal
something that was broken long ago
inside. And this is what Kane did all
his life.
If Citizen Kane is the
story---a tragedy---of a man who is
abandoned (as Hamlet is the tale of a
man who could not make up his mind),
is there anything else important that
can be culled about humanity, flawed
or remarkable, as revealed by Kane?
Absolutely! Rosebud bares something
very profound about Charlie Kane, but
the meaning of Rosebud is not the
whole story. The reporter Thompson is
correct in his comment that one word
does not explain a persons life
(although what we realize about
Rosebud is at the core of Kanes
life). We see also an angry,
rebellious man, an idealist who, like
so many promoting a great ideal, does
not see that he is also a hypocrite.
He is also a man to whom people are
objects that have a function and can
be discarded or neglected when either
they no longer serve a purpose or
have become a problem. The rather
passive Mr Berstein is his business
manager who takes care of all the
messy matters Kane doesnt want
to face. The first Mrs Kane provides
social status and a name. The hated
Mr Thatcher gives him wealth and
represents something about Kane
himself that he does not like to
accept: his materialism. Leland, his
fellow college hell-raiser, is his
entertainer, but like many court
jesters of literature, Jedediah
Leland is also Kanes conscience
(which can be ignored or, if that
cannot be done, resented as when
Charlie finishes Lelands
negative review of Susans opera
debut).
Susan, the second Mrs Kane, the no
talent singer, starts out as a
distraction and later becomes a
hollow reflection of Kane himself. In
the beginning of their relationship
she is an amusement and becomes, like
his Xanadu, something that Kane can
shape and form into his own image.
What he brings out of Susan is
shallow and impaired. One can wonder
how she would have developed if she
had been allowed to be herself and
follow her own star. Like so many who
attempt to impose on others their
vision of who the others should be,
Kane suffocates the special qualities
Susie has in his drive to make her
into something she is not. In a sense
he makes a sows ear out of a
silk purse. In a way he does to Susan
what Thatcher did to him, ignoring
the wonderful qualities while
encouraging something that is not
there. Susan is not a singer, and
Charlie is not a businessman.
If Susan is pathetic, Xanadu is scary
and imposing. Charlie Kanes
great estate and castle represent the
culmination of a life time of
ambitious pursuits. What a weight
Xanadu symbolizes. With all its
appointments and staff, the most
striking features are its shadows and
emptiness. Kane and Susan share this
vast hollow world as if time had
slowed down to a tedius crawl. Life
is missing. Kane has erected an
edifice from his great wealth in
which to hide. He achieves what
people with no wealth achieve by
becoming recluses locked in their
houses, apartments or trailers.
With all his flaws and negative
qualities there is something genuine
and likable about Charlie Kane.
Notice that many people refer to Kane
and his second wife by their first
names. Everyone else is usually
addressed more formally as Mr or Mrs.
There is something rather child-like
about both Charlie and Susan. In a
way Charlies growth was stunted
when on that snowy day,
Charlies mother signed her son
over to Thatcher and sent the boy
away.
Citizen Kane is a film that does
not suffer from repeated viewing, and
I encourage you to see it again. This
time consider the observations that I
have made here. Is there anything
about Kane that feels familiar either
because you can see some of these
qualities in yourself or in another?
|